MedBlogs Grand Rounds 29 July, 2008. ‘Why do we do it?’
Welcome to Grand Rounds! This is my first time hosting, so thanks for your patience as I stumble through. And thanks to everyone who submitted! There are some extremely insightful folks out there, and I’m grateful to showcase their thoughts.
Here’s how I’m setting this up. As I said when I called for submissions, my theme this week is ‘Why do we do it?’ That is, medicine being what it is, many providers (nurses, physicians, PA’s, NP’s, etc) are dissatisfied and frustrated. So why is it that all of these good people keep coming back? Why do docs like me return to the packed, over-burdened, understaffed emergency department, day after day, year after year? Why do surgeons operate at all hours on the injured and dying, aging too quickly and leaving their families at home? Why do family doctors care for so many complicated and ungrateful individuals…at a financial loss? Why do students sacrifice so much of their lives to become physicians? Why do nurses endure the hours and patient ratios, the annoying physicians and the pesky families in order to care for the sick? Why do we do it?
It’s a question I think about quite often, so I wanted everyone else’s thoughts as well.
Now, here’s the layout. The first section will contain links that address the theme. Following that will be some comments from non-bloggers who had something to say after reading my question. They don’t blog, so I’ll be posting their insights here.
The second section will contain links to topics that are not on our theme, but still contain useful, important information that were submitted by people who deserve our attention.
Let me explain section three. Section three will contain links that are basically advertisements. As a free-market capitalist, I’m fine with advertisements as long as we know that’s what they are.
Now, finally, if I mess this up, it’s entirely my fault. Please forgive me if I get something wrong. I’m really not very good with computers, blogging, websites or any of that stuff except the writing itself.
Section One: Why do we do it?
Here’s what I think. We do it for so many reasons. Because it’s exciting, because we love challenges. Because we have families to support and need the money. We sometimes do it for prestige, we sometimes do it for power and control. But what matters to each of us is not why ‘we’ do it, but why ‘I do it.’
I do it for a few reasons. First, because I believe God called me to it. I never intended to be a physician. I wanted to be…lots of things. That wasn’t on the short list when I started college. But it became very important to me, and it has become such a wonderful life, such a great job, such a rewarding experience that I know the hand of the Creator was in it. But more than that, I think he puts the desire to help into our hearts.
We care, not because humans on their own do, but because the need to help the helpless, to heal the sick, is God’s gift to us, and God’s extension of his own hand into our world. Modern health-care requires nothing less than a divine initiative to keep us going, caring for both the best and the worst of humanity, in difficult situations, and often for little earthly reward.
Second, I do it because it’s my way to support my family. The children and wife I was blessed with need things. My work as a physician is an honest way to provide what they need. And a way to show my children that parents provide by working. They need to see me going to and coming from work, and doing my work well and with honor.
Third, I do it because it’s a great laboratory for writing. Patients show us many things as writers, from nuances of language and dialog to the soaring and diving emotions of human experience. Let’s just say, I carry a notepad.
Finally, fourth, and most important, I have come to see that I do it because I love wallowing around in humanity. I love knowing that I’m caring for people as broken and messed up as I am. I love touching them, hearing them, being intertwined, however briefly, in their lives. I love using my hands and brain simultaneously.
I love learning to love them. Medicine, brothers and sisters, is poetry in flesh and blood. Learn the meter and you’ll see more than you ever imagined.
That’s why I do it.
Now, onward and upward!
Edwin
In this post, Anesthesioboist tells, without telling, the shear joy of her work and in the ‘not telling,’ explains why she keeps coming back. This is the way good writing works, friends.
http://anesthesioboist.blogspot.com/2008/07/tales-from-saint-boonies-songs-in-or.html
It isn’t just people who directly care for patients who ask ‘why do we do it?’ Here’s a post from Colorado Health Insurance Insicer, on improving reimbursement for physicians using electronic transfer of billing data. Wait, you do it to help us make more money? Then you’re my hero! Keep up the good work.
http://www.healthinsurancecolorado.net/blog1/2008/07/24/electronic-prescription-transmittal/
Although this post, by South African surgeon Bongi, is not openly related to the theme, it addresses it. Sometimes we do what we do through shear will-power and professionalism. Next time I whine, I’ll have to read this post again. I salute you, doctor. I couldn’t do what you’re doing.
http://other-things-amanzi.blogspot.com/2008/07/im-on-my-way.html
An interesting twist; this blogger addresses ‘why we do it,’ by reminding me why he blogs: to spread the news about coping with pain. In this post, we are treated to a look at the therapeutic benefits of the Wii. Do NOT show my children this post! It would only validate their desire fo a Wii.
http://www.howtocopewithpain.org/blog/194/wii-chronic-pain/
From Hope for Pandora, a middle of the night post on ‘Why?’ Those night-time thoughts are often the best, though sometimes I used to come off of night shifts with the keys to fixing everything, and insights that approached enlightenment. But then, I went to sleep and forgot them. Maybe it was the bacon I ate. Still, this post makes beautiful connections on purpose.
http://hope-for-pandora.blogspot.com/2008/07/typing-my-way-through.html
Some physicians find meaning in moving from medicine proper to larger arenas of interest. Here’s a post from Canadian Medicine on a physician whose interest in climate change is driven by his interest in patient welfare.
http://canadianmedicine.blogspot.com/2008/07/interview-dr-pierre-gosselin-physician.html
This post addresses ‘why we do it’ by showing the results. A well-known and highly respected dietician, she points out how a congressman benefited from proper diet and exercise. Trimming the fat from a congressman seems to have worked well. Now, how about trimming the fat from congress?
http://www.healthline.com/blogs/diet_nutrition/2008/07/way-to-go-congressman-ric-keller.html
From chaplain, English professor and ER volunteer, Susan Palwick, a reflection on why she teaches medical students. Not an easy task, I can tell you. I hope she keeps it up. Medicine without humanity is a terrifying prospect.
http://improbableoptimisms.blogspot.com/2008/07/score-one-for-narrative-medicine.html
Dr. Zhang reminds us, with Yucca plants, Tarantulas and healthy skepticism, that we do what we do out of interest!
http://cockroachcatcher.blogspot.com/2008/07/psychosis-plant-talks-back.html
At last, a reason to become a physician that invokes the power of Star Trek! I love this post. And as a long-time fan of Star Trek, I completely agree…Thanks Dr. R!
http://mymedjokes.blogspot.com/2008/07/my-trek-to-medicine.html
Why we do good things matters. But we must also ask, ‘why do we do evil things?’ This post, from J.C. Jones, MA, RN, asks how psychiatrist and war criminal Karadzic moved from medicine to evil. We may never know the answer, but the question is always relevant.
http://www.healthline.com/blogs/healthline_connects/2008/07/medical-doctors-and-genocide-dr.html
P J Geraghty tells us, not how we providers are special, but how some of our patients families are remarkable. Like those looking through tragedy to organ donation. Why do they do it, I have to ask? Or more to the point, how?
http://evelgeraghty.wordpress.com/2008/07/22/the-ghosts/
Dr. Auerbach gives us National Estimates of Outdoor Injuries. I guess, if you’re going to hike, snowboard or ski, you should do it indoors?
http://www.healthline.com/blogs/outdoor_health/2008/07/national-estimates-of-outdoor.html
Dr. Dee tells us, candidly, that the mountain of debt threatening to fall on him keeps him coming back. I know the truth. It’s what he later tells us; he just likes it! Well, if you like it, you’ll get the debt paid off without even realizing it!
http://www.nzou.com/2008/07/26/why-i-do-it/
I love the answer from Dr. Chan at Rural Doctoring: but I’ll let you read it for her great ending, which sums up what so many physicians feel, and so few can articulate as eloquently.
http://www.ruraldoctoring.com/2008/07/case-metastatic-cancer-week.html
Dr. GC George loves what he does because he is constantly learning from that most amazing of all texts; his patients. Here is a man writing with humility and a great heart. His mother’s prayers, apparently, continue to be answered.
http://www.gcgeorge.net/2008/07/27/why-do-we-do-it/
Why we do it is closely allied to ‘how do we do it?’ and ‘how will we afford it?’ This post by DrRich explores how much money we spend in our attempts to do the right thing.
http://covertrationingblog.com/general-rationing-issues/is-treating-cancer-worth-it
Kerri ,at Six Until Me, explains why she does it. Does what? Keeps moving on, keeps finding happiness despite medical annoyances and set-backs. What’s not to love about a ceramic blue-bird?
http://sixuntilme.com/blog2/2008/07/blue_bird_of_happiness.html
From friend and co-worker Loon1900, a discussion of what motivates an intelligent, capable young man to work as a nurse in an ER full of difficult, ungrateful patients. (And speaking as someone who works there, quite a lot of nutty physicians!) His answer is just what I would expect from someone of his character. Well done.
http://www.xanga.com/loon1900/667910565/item.html
Psychiatrist doctor dymphna, aka Dr. Cordes, loves her work and considers it a ministry. I think she’s absolutely correct in that assessment.
http://drdymphna.wordpress.com/2008/07/28/why-do-i-do-what-i-do/
My friend and former roommate John has an excellent, inspiring, post on why he is still a physician:
http://www.lightalongthejourney.com/?p=688
I have included notes from non-bloggers, who happen to read my blog and want to comment:
Here’s a note from ‘Dr. in training’ Ye, who gives us a most eloquent, lovely, and candid look at the path she took to medical school. I’m glad God directed her in the path she took. (And Dr. Ye, the desire to be useful is a wonderful reason for pursuing medicine!)
Section Two: Assorted links to important topics
Falls: A topic important to me as an Aikido student! As my Sensei says, we’re only born with one fear: the fear of falling. Most Aikido students spend a long time learning to fall, and a longer time learning to make other people fall. But how do we keep the elderly from falling? And most importantly, how do I keep from falling when I get old? That break-fall may not work at 95!
http://neuroanthropology.net/2008/07/21/fall-prevention-in-older-people-stephen-lord-at-hcsnet/
Finding the truth can be elusive when the media gets involved. Ironic, huh? When I was in journalism school, however briefly, we were told that we were ‘gatekeepers of information.’ At the time it sounded heady and cool; now it sounds creepy. Here’s a post on the way the media affects public perception of insurers.
http://insureblog.blogspot.com/2008/07/caitlins-story-jumps-shark.html
Last week I was reading Slate magazine and saw an article on a death in an ER, which occurred while a psychiatric patient was awaiting a bed. I had issues with the conclusions the writer made. I’m glad someone else did as well. Thanks to Emergiblog for this honest, and critical, look at the Slate piece.
http://www.healthline.com/blogs/exercise_fitness/2008/07/new-fitness-fixer-index.htmlFeel like some coffee? Liver feeling ‘out-of-whack?’ Grab some Joe. Pity I hate the stuff. You coffee drinkers may have yet another reason to celebrate your icky, bitter nectar of life. Here’s a post on coffee and liver cancer.http://www.highlighthealth.com/diseases-and-conditions/increased-coffee-consumption-associated-with-lower-risk-of-liver-cancer/
Traveling Doc takes us on a teaching adventure in Borneo. Heck, I’m not sure I ever want to practice anywhere but South Carolina! Thanks for letting us adventure vicariously through you!
http://borneo-breezes.blogspot.com/2008/07/trip-up-mountain.html
From Clinical Cases and Images, here’s an interesting look at whether or not medical bloggers are doing the right thing, and how to do it better! Ouch, maybe I need to go back and do some self-evaluation. A relevant question we should all ask, even as we brush up on our First Amendment rights!
http://casesblog.blogspot.com/2008/07/content-of-weblogs-written-by-health.html
Allergy Notes updates us on giving ARB’s to patients with ACE-inhibitor-related angioedema.
http://allergynotes.blogspot.com/2008/07/can-you-prescribe-arb-to-patient-with.html
As physicians and administrators struggle to mend the safety-nets across the country, The Plain Dealer online medical editor Chris Seper decides to take some action and propose solutions for MetroHealth, Cleveland, on a website devoted to just that topic.
http://www.healthline.com/blogs/pregnancy_childbirth/2008/07/elevated-fsh-and-aneuploidy.htmlThe gracious and insightful Dr. Val interviews former Surgeon General Antonio Novello about creating a Health-care Navigation System for cancer patients.
http://www.revolutionhealth.com/blogs/valjonesmd/dr-antonia-novello–15028
Dr. Shock with advice on how much of ourselves we should disclose to patients. Hint: they don’t need to know your last cholesterol, or how unhappy your parents made you!
http://www.shockmd.com/2008/07/25/patient-doctor-relationship-self-disclosure/
Monash Medical Student uses an episode of House to refresh our memories about Echovirus, echovirus, echovirus, echovirus.
This post is part advertisement, part advice on obtaining health insurance. Plenty of interest in that these days!http://www.besthealthinsurancebook.com/blog/2008/07/25/cant-get-medical-insurance-move-2/For those of us with children who will, one day, go to college (I’m crying already!) a review, by Nancy Brown, PhD, of a book on how to prepare them. Prepare them? How do I prepare me! I’ve got to go tuck someone into bed!http://www.healthline.com/blogs/teen_health/2008/07/book-review-launching-years-part-1.html






great stuff. fascinating read. thanks for including my submission.
Wow! A lot to read here. Great job! Thanks for including my post as well – even if it was off-topic.
WoW! That is an AMAZING ‘Rounds!
Thank you for hosting, and for including our post.
Thanks for including our site. A comprehensive list to say the least!
An interesting approach. Well done. Lots of good reading.
It is the first time I have seen a “commercials” section. I agree it is needed, although I would include some other bloggers, such as the Healthlines folk and wasn’t sure why you included the two that you did. Maybe it will spark some interest in the topic. Great job.
Great Job. I bet you worked late on this one. You are awesome.
Ed,
thanks for all the hard work. I know it took A LOT of time to put all that together.
John
Wow! That is a GRAND rounds! Thanks for all your hard work.
Well done Ed! And I still haven’t finished reading the whole thing…
Thanks for hosting. There is such a lot to go through. Thanks for including my post. Medicine could be fun.
The Cockroach Catcher
Dear Edwin
I can’t agree more with everything you wrote. While I read it I felt like if I was reading my feelings and thoughts about my own work. I am an Internist, working in the ER of one of the government’s Hospitals in Guatemala, Central America. With our very, very limited resources here, many times one have to face the sufferings of this patients with any on hand but hope. What a powerful word! I am so grateful to God for calling me to serve others with this amazing profession. You are a great example for all of us.
Thank you
Myriam
Good design blog. Author fellow, will be your constant visitor. I learned many interesting thanks.