This summer, Sam, my oldest son, had appendicitis. Like all doctor’s kids, his diagnosis eluded me. Until, three days into his pain, when his brother Seth said, ‘Papa, Sam is hurting. You need to check on him!’ Sure enough, his exam was worse than before. After labs and a CT scan, we found that his appendix was behind his colon, and needed to come out into the light of day.
His care was great. I’m still singing the praises of Dr. Pete Gilbert and his nurse Lori, of Oconee Memorial Hospital, for the care they gave my first-born boy. He was back on his feet in two days. He never had any hint of infection. I couldn’t have asked for more. My son was healthy and back to normal.
Looking back, our experience was a wonderful one. And it gave me a lot of insight, not only into how it feels (once again) to have a sick family member, but into the economics of medicine.
Now, Sam was in the hospital for a little less than 24 hours, door to door. He had a CT scan and surgery, antibiotics, pain medication and IV fluids. He had all the things that go with it, including dressings, etc. His hospital bill (minus surgeon’s fee) was around $20,000.
I am not complaining. Please don’t get me wrong. I’d be a hypocrite if I said it was a ridiculous bill. I’m thankful to God above for my job and the insurance I have that helps me to care for my family, both in crisis and in maintenance of things like Seth’s Insulin pump.
But, something occurred to me about the bill. Let’s face it, Sam probably didn’t get $20,000 worth of care, medication and supplies. But what Sam did do is cover his surgery, and maybe three or four others. I can believe he received $5000 worth of care. It seems reasonable. So really, his surgery paid for his own care, and about $5000 worth of care for several others.
Now, why don’t we just acknowledge that? In the Torah, we read the concept of the ‘Year of Jubilee.’ A year in which, in ancient Israel, debts were forgiven. Why don’t we do this, honestly, with medical bills?
See, I can pay my bill. But the guy working for minimum wage will have a hard time. Fortunately, my son’s bill paid for his son’s bill. So let’s be up front and write his off! I mean, we talk about how much debt people and hospitals are in. But are they? If every bill is a bill inflated in order to cover other bills, what’s the real debt?
I’m not saying we have to write off every bill. Money has to come in, so that the system will continue. And most likely, profit has to be made. It’s unrealistic to envision a system of medical excellence in which the organizations and workers can’t work hard to make more money. We demand excellence in our technology. We become angry when our computers give us problems. Do we really want a system of mediocrity in health-care?
But we need to be fair and just. In the book of the Prophet Micah, Micah says, ‘He has shown you, oh man, what is good. And what does the Lord require of you but to do justice, and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God?’
I think we could be more just, and more merciful to the uninsured by reducing their inflated debt to a more reasonable actual debt. And since the insured already bear the weight of the uninsured, why not be honest about it and write off some debt? It seems a way to avoid a truly socialized disaster, by applying something that would keep government involvement at bay, and still ease the weight of health-care costs for those who really can’t afford them.
It seems a simple thing to me; but I’m a simple-minded guy.
Income less than Federal Poverty Level = 100% discount
Income less than 200% FPL = 75% discount
Income less than 300% FPL = 50% discount
Income less than 400% FPL = 25% discount
And sending patients to collection generally yeilds almost no revenue and lots of bad PR, so our facility rarely bothers.
A better question might be why someone at 400% FPL only gets a 25% discount when insurance companies and medicare patients get much steeper discounts…
I think your idea could be easily tied to the Mary Bono bill allowing deduction of uncompensated debt (add to the bill debt forgiven)from Federal income tax for docs and hospitals under EMTALA.
You’re right, collections for those folks are generally worthless. However, there are a few who probably should be pursued, who know what they’re doing, refuse to pay, and still buy nice trucks, etc.
Edwin
spatterso
17 years ago
Your comment about the Mary Bono bill is absolutely the way to go. The federal government is unfortunately not going to be very willing to make that happen. The uncompensated care that occurs as a result of EMTALA is a strong motivator in the steady rise in health care costs as people abuse the system. I had a patient just last night who told me, when asked if she had a primary physician, “I just use the ER, so I don’t have to pay for insurance”. Perhaps when patients begin to realize the true economics of health care, the bill… Read more »
EEJ
17 years ago
As an FYI, I have a friend who is about 30. He’s been paying off his bill for having his appendix removed for 5 years now. He’s single, and doesn’t make a lot of money (and had no insurance at the time of the surgery). He had bad stomach pains and was told his appendix needed to come out. During the surgery to remove it, the surgeon realized that the appendix did not have any signs of needing to come out, but they removed it anyways. They also realized while they were doing the surgery that he actually had an… Read more »
Good ideas. Do the “hospitals” really know and would they admit what the actual cost of a 24hr/appy/CT/etc is? Discounts, yep, why charge $111 for an ultrasound when Medicare recognizes $27 as an adequate/appropriate/”all I Will pay” amount. System’s out of balance!
Well, I guess Hell must be on the verge of freezing over: Shadowfax and I are actually singing from the same page on this. One of the functions I perform at my hospital is to approve applications for just the kind of program that Shadowfax outlines, and our policy (and scale) is pretty much as he describes. Despite being the soulless finance guy, I actually give away a good bit of care this way (many millions of dollars worth). And, as much as I enjoy persecuting widows and orphans, it really isn’t good business to authorize collection activity for people… Read more »
[…] He had mentioned his “latest blog post on why that CT cost $8000, or something ridiculous like that, and what we should do with that bill.” I tried to get to his blog but the link on his name took me to a Blogger ‘profile not available’ page. Google to the rescue and I found his blog and the post in question, which was basically about his son’s appendicitis and surgery. […]
sistemi enalotto
16 years ago
I dont even remember how i reached your site but it doesnt matter, cause i’m so happy i found it, it really made me think, keep up the good work
login
16 years ago
de, – Sunday, February 22, 2004 at 11:47:29 (PST)
Gary
15 years ago
It would make more sense if hospitals ran their businesses like businesses. The reason your computer does not cost $20K is because of market competition. You, as a consumer, know how much a computer costs before you buy. If the price is too high, you go to the store across the street. That is why computers are high quality items at low prices. As a result, even poor people can afford one. Imagine if hospitals all had price lists. They could not just charge whatever. They would have to make sure their fees are competitive. Socialized medicine designed to help… Read more »
I completely agree! Run for office! I’d be happy to practice that way, because I know I could make a decent living and charge a fare rate to all. And charity would be far easier than it is!
Definitely agree with simply what you whispered. Your description was surely the simplest to comprehend. I tell you, I typically grow annoyed any time individuals discuss issues that these persons observably don’t know about. You were capable to hit the nail on the head as well as spelled out the whole thing with out complication. Perhaps, individuals could take a signal. Will likely be back to obtain more. Appreciate it.
{"id":null,"mode":"form","open_style":"in_place","currency_code":"USD","currency_symbol":"$","currency_type":"decimal","blank_flag_url":"https:\/\/edwinleap.com\/wp-content\/plugins\/tip-jar-wp\/\/assets\/images\/flags\/blank.gif","flag_sprite_url":"https:\/\/edwinleap.com\/wp-content\/plugins\/tip-jar-wp\/\/assets\/images\/flags\/flags.png","default_amount":100,"top_media_type":"none","featured_image_url":false,"featured_embed":"","header_media":null,"file_download_attachment_data":null,"recurring_options_enabled":true,"recurring_options":{"never":{"selected":true,"after_output":"One time only"},"weekly":{"selected":false,"after_output":"Every week"},"monthly":{"selected":false,"after_output":"Every month"},"yearly":{"selected":false,"after_output":"Every year"}},"strings":{"current_user_email":"","current_user_name":"","link_text":"Leave a tip","complete_payment_button_error_text":"Check info and try again","payment_verb":"Pay","payment_request_label":"EdwinLeap.com","form_has_an_error":"Please check and fix the errors above","general_server_error":"Something isn't working right at the moment. Please try again.","form_title":"EdwinLeap.com","form_subtitle":"If you enjoy the content you read here, please consider dropping something in the tip jar!","currency_search_text":"Country or Currency here","other_payment_option":"Other payment option","manage_payments_button_text":"Manage your payments","thank_you_message":"Thank you so much! I appreciate the tip!","payment_confirmation_title":"EdwinLeap.com","receipt_title":"Your Receipt","print_receipt":"Print Receipt","email_receipt":"Email Receipt","email_receipt_sending":"Sending receipt...","email_receipt_success":"Email receipt successfully sent","email_receipt_failed":"Email receipt failed to send. Please try again.","receipt_payee":"Paid to","receipt_statement_descriptor":"This will show up on your statement as","receipt_date":"Date","receipt_transaction_id":"Transaction ID","receipt_transaction_amount":"Amount","refund_payer":"Refund from","login":"Log in to manage your payments","manage_payments":"Manage Payments","transactions_title":"Your Transactions","transaction_title":"Transaction Receipt","transaction_period":"Plan Period","arrangements_title":"Your Plans","arrangement_title":"Manage Plan","arrangement_details":"Plan Details","arrangement_id_title":"Plan ID","arrangement_payment_method_title":"Payment Method","arrangement_amount_title":"Plan Amount","arrangement_renewal_title":"Next renewal date","arrangement_action_cancel":"Cancel Plan","arrangement_action_cant_cancel":"Cancelling is currently not available.","arrangement_action_cancel_double":"Are you sure you'd like to cancel?","arrangement_cancelling":"Cancelling Plan...","arrangement_cancelled":"Plan Cancelled","arrangement_failed_to_cancel":"Failed to cancel plan","back_to_plans":"\u2190 Back to Plans","update_payment_method_verb":"Update","sca_auth_description":"Your have a pending renewal payment which requires authorization.","sca_auth_verb":"Authorize renewal payment","sca_authing_verb":"Authorizing payment","sca_authed_verb":"Payment successfully authorized!","sca_auth_failed":"Unable to authorize! Please try again.","login_button_text":"Log in","login_form_has_an_error":"Please check and fix the errors above","uppercase_search":"Search","lowercase_search":"search","uppercase_page":"Page","lowercase_page":"page","uppercase_items":"Items","lowercase_items":"items","uppercase_per":"Per","lowercase_per":"per","uppercase_of":"Of","lowercase_of":"of","back":"Back to plans","zip_code_placeholder":"Zip\/Postal Code","download_file_button_text":"Download File","input_field_instructions":{"tip_amount":{"placeholder_text":"How much would you like to tip?","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"How much would you like to tip? Choose any currency."},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"How much would you like to tip? Choose any currency."},"invalid_curency":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Please choose a valid currency."}},"recurring":{"placeholder_text":"Recurring","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"How often would you like to give this?"},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"How often would you like to give this?"},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"How often would you like to give this?"}},"name":{"placeholder_text":"Name on Credit Card","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Enter the name on your card."},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"Enter the name on your card."},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Please enter the name on your card."}},"privacy_policy":{"terms_title":"Terms and conditions","terms_body":null,"terms_show_text":"View Terms","terms_hide_text":"Hide Terms","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"I agree to the terms."},"unchecked":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Please agree to the terms."},"checked":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"I agree to the terms."}},"email":{"placeholder_text":"Your email address","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Enter your email address"},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"Enter your email address"},"blank":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Enter your email address"},"not_an_email_address":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Make sure you have entered a valid email address"}},"note_with_tip":{"placeholder_text":"Your note here...","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Attach a note to your tip (optional)"},"empty":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Attach a note to your tip (optional)"},"not_empty_initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Attach a note to your tip (optional)"},"saving":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Saving note..."},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"Note successfully saved!"},"error":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Unable to save note note at this time. Please try again."}},"email_for_login_code":{"placeholder_text":"Your email address","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Enter your email to log in."},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"Enter your email to log in."},"blank":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Enter your email to log in."},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Enter your email to log in."}},"login_code":{"initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Check your email and enter the login code."},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"Check your email and enter the login code."},"blank":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Check your email and enter the login code."},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Check your email and enter the login code."}},"stripe_all_in_one":{"initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Enter your credit card details here."},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Enter your credit card details here."},"success":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Enter your credit card details here."},"invalid_number":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card number is not a valid credit card number."},"invalid_expiry_month":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's expiration month is invalid."},"invalid_expiry_year":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's expiration year is invalid."},"invalid_cvc":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's security code is invalid."},"incorrect_number":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card number is incorrect."},"incomplete_number":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card number is incomplete."},"incomplete_cvc":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's security code is incomplete."},"incomplete_expiry":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's expiration date is incomplete."},"incomplete_zip":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's zip code is incomplete."},"expired_card":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card has expired."},"incorrect_cvc":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's security code is incorrect."},"incorrect_zip":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's zip code failed validation."},"invalid_expiry_year_past":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's expiration year is in the past"},"card_declined":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card was declined."},"missing":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"There is no card on a customer that is being charged."},"processing_error":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"An error occurred while processing the card."},"invalid_request_error":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Unable to process this payment, please try again or use alternative method."},"invalid_sofort_country":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The billing country is not accepted by SOFORT. Please try another country."}}}},"fetched_oembed_html":false}
Most hospitals do write off the bills for the uninsured. Ask your hospital’s CFO — you may be surprised.
A typical scheme may be:
Income
Dang. HTML got me.
Income less than Federal Poverty Level = 100% discount
Income less than 200% FPL = 75% discount
Income less than 300% FPL = 50% discount
Income less than 400% FPL = 25% discount
And sending patients to collection generally yeilds almost no revenue and lots of bad PR, so our facility rarely bothers.
A better question might be why someone at 400% FPL only gets a 25% discount when insurance companies and medicare patients get much steeper discounts…
I think your idea could be easily tied to the Mary Bono bill allowing deduction of uncompensated debt (add to the bill debt forgiven)from Federal income tax for docs and hospitals under EMTALA.
You’re right, collections for those folks are generally worthless. However, there are a few who probably should be pursued, who know what they’re doing, refuse to pay, and still buy nice trucks, etc.
Edwin
Your comment about the Mary Bono bill is absolutely the way to go. The federal government is unfortunately not going to be very willing to make that happen. The uncompensated care that occurs as a result of EMTALA is a strong motivator in the steady rise in health care costs as people abuse the system. I had a patient just last night who told me, when asked if she had a primary physician, “I just use the ER, so I don’t have to pay for insurance”. Perhaps when patients begin to realize the true economics of health care, the bill… Read more »
As an FYI, I have a friend who is about 30. He’s been paying off his bill for having his appendix removed for 5 years now. He’s single, and doesn’t make a lot of money (and had no insurance at the time of the surgery). He had bad stomach pains and was told his appendix needed to come out. During the surgery to remove it, the surgeon realized that the appendix did not have any signs of needing to come out, but they removed it anyways. They also realized while they were doing the surgery that he actually had an… Read more »
Good ideas. Do the “hospitals” really know and would they admit what the actual cost of a 24hr/appy/CT/etc is? Discounts, yep, why charge $111 for an ultrasound when Medicare recognizes $27 as an adequate/appropriate/”all I Will pay” amount. System’s out of balance!
Well, I guess Hell must be on the verge of freezing over: Shadowfax and I are actually singing from the same page on this. One of the functions I perform at my hospital is to approve applications for just the kind of program that Shadowfax outlines, and our policy (and scale) is pretty much as he describes. Despite being the soulless finance guy, I actually give away a good bit of care this way (many millions of dollars worth). And, as much as I enjoy persecuting widows and orphans, it really isn’t good business to authorize collection activity for people… Read more »
[…] He had mentioned his “latest blog post on why that CT cost $8000, or something ridiculous like that, and what we should do with that bill.” I tried to get to his blog but the link on his name took me to a Blogger ‘profile not available’ page. Google to the rescue and I found his blog and the post in question, which was basically about his son’s appendicitis and surgery. […]
I dont even remember how i reached your site but it doesnt matter, cause i’m so happy i found it, it really made me think, keep up the good work
de, – Sunday, February 22, 2004 at 11:47:29 (PST)
It would make more sense if hospitals ran their businesses like businesses. The reason your computer does not cost $20K is because of market competition. You, as a consumer, know how much a computer costs before you buy. If the price is too high, you go to the store across the street. That is why computers are high quality items at low prices. As a result, even poor people can afford one. Imagine if hospitals all had price lists. They could not just charge whatever. They would have to make sure their fees are competitive. Socialized medicine designed to help… Read more »
Gary,
I completely agree! Run for office! I’d be happy to practice that way, because I know I could make a decent living and charge a fare rate to all. And charity would be far easier than it is!
Your content is valid and informative in my private opinion. You might have truly done lots of research on this subject. Thanks for sharing it.
Definitely agree with simply what you whispered. Your description was surely the simplest to comprehend. I tell you, I typically grow annoyed any time individuals discuss issues that these persons observably don’t know about. You were capable to hit the nail on the head as well as spelled out the whole thing with out complication. Perhaps, individuals could take a signal. Will likely be back to obtain more. Appreciate it.