• Get in touch
The wreck of the good ship, EMTALA

EMTALA, the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act, was passed in 1986.  For those who aren’t familiar with yet another acronym, EMTALA is a federal law that was enacted to keep poor, uninsured patients from being ‘dumped’ on indigent-care hospitals, or any other facility, for financial reasons.  Although it was a good idea, it soon grew fangs, tentacles, claws, rose up to several hundred stories in height and developed a surly attitude and bad breath.  It is, in fact, one of the largest unfunded mandates the US legislative branch has ever gifted on its subjects.
For those of us who practice emergency medicine, and by now any medicine in a hospital that accepts Medicare payments, no one can be turned away for financial reasons.  On the surface, this seems fair.  Certainly, the potential exists for gross harm and injustice if we refuse to care for the most needy in our populations because we aren’t getting paid.  ‘Your child is having non-stop seizures, eh?  Well, pony up $400 we’ll see what we can do!’  It makes sense to have a provision of protection.

However, because this law basically forbids hospitals and physicians from saying ‘no,’ (without a complex, time consuming, legally perilous screening exam that is rarely worth the effort), we see all those who come through the door.  And because the ‘cat is out of the bag’ and has been for a while, many of our patients know this.  So, we have these conversations.

Doctor:   ‘I see you have a toothache.  Have you seen your dentist?’

Patient:  ‘No, I owe him money.’

or

Doctor:  ‘You know, you’ve been here every week for the last six months for chest pain, and you’ve had every test we can do.  It isn’t anything dangerous, yet you keep asking for pain medication, you refuse to follow up with anyone, and now owe our group $7000.’

Patient:  ‘Right, interesting.  So, today it goes around my back, to my ear, down my arm and into my testicle.  What do you think it is?’

It isn’t that we don’t take people seriously, because we do.  It isn’t that we don’t want to help, because we do.  But medicine being our business, money is often part of the transaction after the smoke has cleared.

Equally problematic, surgeons, neurologists, cardiologists, otolaryngologists and just about every other ‘ist’ is burdened with the same issue.  The people they see in the ER,  admit to the floor, or take to surgery or the cardiac cath lab will frequently be unable to pay anything, but then still be able to sue for millions of dollars.  It’s hard for specialists to run practices when large numbers of patients pay nothing for their care.  I understand their issues here.  I don’t blame them a bit for being angry.

And of course, hospitals are providing care that isn’t reimbursed to patients who can’t, or intend never to pay them.  Nurses and other staff are cut.  Rooms aren’t available, needed additions aren’t built, new technologies are hard to afford, other specialists can’t be recruited, and before you can blink a hospital is closing or reducing it’s capacity.  And to top it off, we can’t even get the Smucker’s peanut butter cups we all used to scarf from the patient supply cabinet while seeing sick people!  Woe is me!
Across America, small and medium sized emergency departments and hospitals are closing.  Trauma centers and teaching hospitals are struggling and overwhelmed.  And specialists are simply leaving hospital care in order to avoid being on call, and the attendant EMTALA responsibilities that call entails.  They’re working in surgery/outpatient centers. They’re leaving the setting where they are compelled to give care away, and where they are constantly overwhelmed by more and more demand, less and less payment.

Our own group sees increased volume every time we increase staffing.  The numbers, the lack of control, the degree of genuine illness, and the degree of ridiculous visits for life crises, narcotic abuse, work excuses or just ‘because I was here with my friend anyway,’ keep rising.  Can we say no?  Not much, not often.

You see, the federal government thought EMTALA seemed like a nice, friendly, warm-hearted way to help America’s indigent populations.  It also thought it seemed like a cheap way to do it, since EMTALA didn’t come with any money for providers or hospitals to do this epic work of securing the ‘health-care safety net.’  Like so many government programs it consists of untold numbers of legislators and government functionaries patting themselves on the back for helping the poor by having someone else pay for it and do the work; that is, America’s hospitals and physicians.

But here’s the final irony.  EMTALA has created the very conditions it sought to avoid.  Now, with specialists unavailable, hospitals full, transfers always difficult and no lack of genuinely sick and dying patients, there’s often 1) no one to care for them and 2) no place to put or send them.  EMTALA, the federal mandate to save the poor from sickness has begun to crumble at its foundations, and leave untold numbers of patients, poor and paying, without care.

This isn’t meant to be a tirade about payment, though non-medical readers may see it that way.  What I’m getting at is that our system, our government mandated system, is a failure.

You might make the argument that nationalized health-care can fix this with money, but as we see in so many problems, money doesn’t do much.  Money in the school system still leaves us with staggering drop-out rates and high-school illiteracy.  Money, in the hands of an irresistible, un-yielding, entitlement crazy, grandiosity-leaning government system will probably result in an even greater disaster than EMTALA.

My suggestion?  Get the government out of it all.  If you do, the poor will likely get better care, since we’ll be able to screen out and turn away those who abuse their privilege.  And doctors, that pesky, generally unimportant part of the medical equation, will actually return to hospitals and be available; out of a sense of duty, professionalism, entrepreneurial spirit and genuine compassion without federal compulsion.

It’s unlikely to happen, but a doctor can dream.  ‘And then I saw a scarecrow and some flying monkeys and a witch, and a hospital where I was in charge and could always do what I thought was right, oh Auntie Em, it was wonderful!’

Yours,

Edwin

Share this:
About the author
Edwin

30 Comments

Steve

2008-05-08 23:02:35 Reply

Continue to elect the same buggers to Congress…that way none of your dreams will be realized. Take responsibility by electing people that won’t “give” away our country.

Steve

Patrick

2008-05-09 01:07:53 Reply

EMTALA and JCAHO are the two biggest obstacles to effective, efficient and compassionate care for all. All in the name of fairness and excellence.

Pathetic.

girlvet

2008-05-09 19:48:00 Reply

All true. Recently the dept of homeland security counted ER beds available in big cities on a certain date, at a certain time and found few available. The idea was how many would be available in a terrorist attack. Who do you think were probably taking up half of these beds?

Mike

2008-05-10 00:19:58 Reply

No one listens to doctors anymore. Neither will Congress.

I just read your article in Medical Economics. Congratulations. It was nice.

Tammy, MD

2008-05-11 00:08:37 Reply

Once again, Dr. Leap, you are a voice of reason in what seems like an ocean of nonsense! I practice in small town ED (census 46K visits/year) and have watched my list of specialists on call dwindle (No ENT, GI, Urology, Neurology, or Opthomology.. don’t even think about neurosurg, plastics, trauma surgery) I’ll be honest…it has gotten downright frightening! This winter was a nightmare since most of the “big city” hospital beds were filled to the brim. My ortho guys cringe to take any call, because they get pulled out of an office of paying patients to see patients who will never pay them but not hesitate to sue them if the doctor’s socks didn’t match that day.

Thank you for reassuring me that I am not alone in this battle! I just hope that my patients (and my medical license!) can survive the ordeal.

Mike Zemack

2008-05-13 01:51:29 Reply

The “silent protest” by doctors and specialists walking away from hospital practice is certainly appropriate and moral. And I agree fully that we should “Get the government out of it all.” But it doesn’t have to be just a dream.

The real power in the health care arena is the doctor, and he should use it. Fleeing the hospitals for surgery/outpatient centers or some other means of practice is only a short-term fix. The politicians will eventually go after them wherever they go.

The best, and likely the only, way to turn the tide toward a full-fledged government-run health care dictatorship is for the doctors to stand up en masse for their rights. Doctors are “that pesky, generally unimportant part of the medical equation” only so long as they allow this to be the case. An uncompromising and principled stand against the state would stop socialized medicine dead in its tracks.

That is my dream.

ninguem

2008-05-13 20:55:11 Reply

Is this a new position for you Dr. Leap?

I’ve long held the position that EMTALA makes things worse, but I seem to be under the impression that EM physicians did not share the feeling. I don’t think we’ll have any action on this law until organized Emergency Medicine takes the position that the law should be repealed.

911DOC

2008-05-17 09:00:30 Reply

dear dr leap.
long, long time fan. now that i have a semi-successful blog i find myself linking you quite frequently and you are linked for this one my friend. at the time you were writing this piece i was writing two others which you can peruse if you choose. when are we going to link arms as physicians and hold our breath until we change this idiocy? the sermo letter is namby pamby and i’ll have a suggested letter up soon. please keep it up, my wife and i love your stuff.
me

http://docsontheweb.blogspot.com/2008/05/consults-circa-emtala.html

http://docsontheweb.blogspot.com/2008/05/all-your-medical-news-right-here.html

Melinda

2008-05-31 04:28:21 Reply

Long, long ago, I took a friend to a local community hospital/medicaid clinic to seek treatment for his headache. It turned out he had a mild sinus infection, easily treated. But we had to wait approximately eight hours in a small, cramped waiting room before he got to speak with a doctor.

Nationalized health care would be this, but worse. Instead of waiting eight hours, the hours would turn into days and weeks, maybe even months. This has been the experience of many of my Canadian friends who live under a nationalized health care system. “You need cataract surgery and a hip replacement. Your first opportunity for the surgery will be in four months. You won’t mind laying in bed, blind, for the next four months, will you?”

With good insurance, I’m spoiled with the ability to schedule an appointment, walk into my doctor’s office, and be in and out in just a couple of hours. I cannot imagine that the American public would willing accept the longer waits (and significantly higher taxes) that nationalized health care would necessitate.

Kenneth Ellenberg

2010-01-10 16:20:06 Reply

Although it may sound a bit corny, I in reality like looking after my hearing and whilst I do agree with the preceding poster and I really hope I do not get shot down for saying this, but I think it is essential to take all things in moderation.

buy my house as is

2011-09-14 01:37:54 Reply

19.) Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thank you However I am experiencing issue with ur rss . Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting identical rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

Jeff Dantin

2011-12-07 08:04:13 Reply

I have learned new things from a blog post. Also a thing to I have observed is that in many instances, FSBO sellers can reject people. Remember, they might prefer to not ever use your services. But if a person maintain a gentle, professional relationship, offering guide and staying in contact for about four to five weeks, you will usually have the ability to win a meeting. From there, a house listing follows. Many thanks

car scratch remover

2012-02-08 08:09:22 Reply

Youre one of the good guys here, and we know that. Its not the numbers, its the abuse.

Lucien Fitzgibbons

2012-02-10 22:43:58 Reply

Hello there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it is truly informative. I am gonna watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful if you continue this in future. A lot of people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! It’s perfect time to make some plans for the future and it’s time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I want to suggest you some interesting things or tips. Maybe you can write next articles referring to this article. I want to read more things about it! Great post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Very useful info particularly the last part :) I care for such information a lot.

rechargeable hearing aid battery

2012-03-29 15:09:57 Reply

As many have no doubt noted already, the supreme irony of this contest is if a guy named Kennedy effectively throws the Kennedy seat to the GOP.

Vending Services

2012-03-29 18:28:32 Reply

I had been wanting to know if you ever thought of replacing the layout of your web site? Its very well written; I enjoy what you have got to say. But maybe you can create a a bit more in the way of content so people can connect with it better. You have got an awful lot of text for only having one or two graphics. Maybe you can space it out better?

Anthony Barthelemy

2012-03-31 03:49:12 Reply

Hey, I found webblog is awfully attention-grabbing. I liked your webblog a lot. Thanks again for sharing this online. I certainly loved every part of it.

direct mail fulfillment services

2012-04-26 15:43:30 Reply

Yeah, those Garmin doohickeys are kinda magical. I might have to get one now. Oh dear.

pilates courses for beginners

2012-05-03 02:56:33 Reply

weak erection cure weak erection treatment how to fix erection problems how to fix impotence how to get a bigger erection naturally over the counter impotence drugs best pills for erectile dysfunction difficulty getting an erection natural food for strong erection over the counter erection impotence treatments herbal natural male enhancement drugs strong erection exercises losing erection during foreplay reasons for lack of erection male enhancer products erectile dysfunction treatment injection treating erectile dysfunction tips how to maintain an erection men losing erection otc male enhancement pills which ed pill is the best problem with erection erection pills uk maintain erection long time i cannot maintain an erection impotence herbal remedy keep losing erection trouble getting full erection all natural male enhancement pills

Julio Deras

2012-05-22 04:11:36 Reply

Cool article it is really. Friend on mine has been waiting for this update.

payday loans online no credit check

2012-07-30 19:35:07 Reply

This excellent website certainly has all the information I wanted about this subject and didn’t know who to ask.

Read Full Article

2012-08-01 10:52:20 Reply

Everything is very open with a clear explanation of the challenges. It was truly informative. Your site is very useful. Many thanks for sharing!

More Bonuses

2012-08-03 07:24:04 Reply

I couldn’t resist commenting. Perfectly written!

Caroyln

2012-10-21 23:26:50 Reply

I’m commenting to let you know of the outstanding encounter my cousin’s child went through reading the blog. She figured out a lot of pieces, most notably what it is like to have a very effective helping nature to make a number of people without difficulty fully understand several impossible topics. You actually exceeded readers’ desires. I appreciate you for producing these informative, trustworthy, revealing as well as unique guidance on this topic to Lizeth.

Pete

2012-10-22 15:21:43 Reply

Thanks for all your efforts on this website. Gloria loves going through investigations and it is obvious why. Most people notice all of the dynamic method you convey very useful ideas on the blog and therefore welcome response from website visitors about this idea so my child is undoubtedly starting to learn a lot. Enjoy the remaining portion of the new year. You are performing a really good job.

Steward

2013-02-25 16:23:17 Reply

Hi there! I just want to give a huge thumbs up for the great info you have got here on this post. I might be coming back to your blog for extra soon.

Alverta Feldkamp

2013-04-03 06:26:03 Reply

You’ve made my day! Thank you again

anti snoring

2013-06-23 02:14:28 Reply

Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It actually was a entertainment account it.
Glance complex to more added agreeable from you! By the
way, how could we communicate?

Leave a Comment