« Older Home
Loading Newer »

Grand Rounds for January 6th: Profit in medicine and other cool stuff!

This is the location for Medblogs Grandrounds, January 6, 2008.  Our topic?  The value, or detriment, of financial profit in health-care.  From doctors to pharmaceutical companies, universities to insurers and everything in between; is profit good or bad?

Well, obviously not everyone wants to write on my topic.  So here are the submissions.  Lots of interesting posts from very interesting writers, writing from many different angles; nurses, patients, insurers, lawyers, therapists, students and all the rest.

So, since it’s my turn to host, I go first.  Here’s what I have to say about profit in medicine.  Every difficult, life-changing, dangerous, critical, exhausting job requires reward.  In fact, every kind of work requires some reward, but that’s not what we’re discussing here.

Physicians have to be paid well in order to continue to practice medicine.  It wasn’t always this way.  Because, there was a time in modern medicine when the rewards of the practice of medicine were considered higher than mere cash.  Why did early physicians expose themselves to epidemics and death?  Why did they go to battlefields and learn surgery?  Why did they labor with the miserable and poor?  Because they sensed the value of human-kind.  They were taught, and believed, that every life was valuable in God’s eyes, and that if they ignored their calling, and ignored suffering, they would face God’s wrath.  They also believed that if they did right, if they endured under hardship, if they died of the diseases they fought against, they would be rewarded by their Creator.

We are too modern for all that, now, aren’t we?  We don’t need mumbo-jumbo, irrational, anti-scientific theories about human worth.  We’re post-moderns!  We will do right, because it’s good for mankind and good for society and because our reward will be…well, it will be science and knowledge…I mean, it will be the survival of all the fittest for the collective good of mankind in a few eons…it will be…a good review from my boss and a nice retirement with a boat…it will be a vacation and a car and….well, some money will do nicely, if you please.

Reject transcendence if you will.  But if you do, prepare large boxes of cash.  Because doctors without a sense of temporal and eternal purpose will have to be rewarded financially in order to stay in a long, arduous educational system, in order to work all hours, in order to expose themselves to risks physical, emotional and legal and in order to come back day after day to a job that is sometimes amazing but often quite tedious and frequently quite maddening.

It’s cute that medical students and pre-med students like the idea of working for less if their educations are paid by the government.  But that attitude won’t last.  Ask folks who went to medical school on military scholarships.  And ask them how long they stayed in the military.  Eventually, the realities of this job in a post-enlightenment world catch up, and everyone wants money.
All that aside, medicine is a valuable profession and valuable professions are simply worth a good living.  Should doctors be stingy thieves?  No.  Should we be fair?  Yes.

Are we fair?  Yes, I think for the most part we are fair, and good and compassionate.  I’ve met very few physicians, in emergency medicine at least, who wouldn’t bend over backwards to help someone who was truly sick and truly dying.

Now, you’ll also need money to get physicians and mid-level providers to continue seeing all of the nonsense we see; the lifestyle-choice based diseases, the ridiculous midnight requests to do sports physicals, the insane ‘I’m out of my MS Conin, Percocet, Klonopin and Fentanyl patches’ complaints.  Of course, that sort of ridiculous abuse of the system should probably be the topic of another Grand Rounds.

So be careful about re-ordering the existing ‘natural order,’ in medicine.  Because if we decide that profit is inherently bad, we’re going to have a tough time getting things like new medicines from companies, new procedures from surgeons and open office slots from any doctor on earth.

Until we re-discover Hippocrates, and what he was saying all those years ago, we’ll just have to do one of two things:  keep paying people lots of money, or learn to do without care.

That’s the way I see it, anyhow!

Now, read on and enjoy today’s Grand Rounds.

First, a technical note about subscribing to Grand Rounds, from Walter Jessen of Highlight Health http://www.highlighthealth.com

Don’t forget, Grand Rounds now has subscription options - you can follow by email or RSS feed: http://feedproxy.google.com/GrandRoundsBlogCarnival

An aggregated feed of credible, rotating health and medicine blog carnivals is also available: http://feedproxy.google.com/HealthAndMedicineBlogCarnivals

On to the show:  (Of course, unlike Grand Rounds in medical school and residency, you’re all here because you want to be, no one has worn the same clothes for three days and it’s doubtful you’re passing out on the computer, spilling your coffee and praying that your faculty doesn’t call on you.)

Kim at Emergiblog boldly suggests that profit motive isn’t the
problem, that primary care is something we desperately need more of,
and that the plan out lined by Physicians for National Health Care may
be just the ticket to maintaining incomes and encouraging doctors to
be doctors.  Go Kim!  Thanks for an excellent, well-articulated post.

http://www.emergiblog.com/2009/01/primary-care-profit-is-not-a-dirty-word.htm

At medschoolforfools, we have what I consider a reasonable,
well-thought defense of the profit motive in medicine.  My advice?
Hire this young doctor when he finishes training.  He’ll work hard and
do the right thing…you can bank on it.  Pun intended.

http://medschoolforfools.blogspot.com/2009/01/success-money-and-medicine.html

Medical librarian Laika discusses the merits of evidence based
medicine vs. web 2.0 based resources in a well-thought post that also
addresses one of my questions, that is ‘is everything we do, and
recommend, really evidence based and in the best interest of our
patients?’  Laika is clearly very intelligent.  After reading this
post I felt like I needed to join the other hominids and go touch the
monolith.  Well said, Laika!

http://laikaspoetnik.wordpress.com/2009/01/04/the-web-20-ebm-medicine-split-1-introduction-into-a-short- series/

Liana reminds us, in photographic eloquence, that medicine is far, far
more than profit.  Thank you for the gift of your camera and your
compassion.

http://medvalleyhigh.blogspot.com/2009/01/belated-post.html

Colorado Health Insurance Insider suggests that primary care would be
more attractive if it were a government-salaried position, without all
of the hassles of the current system.  We may just get to test that
hypothesis…

http://www.healthinsurancecolorado.net/blog1/2008/07/28/attracting-more-docs-to-primary-care/

Scalpel illustrates with absolute transparency the reasons that ankle
sprains cost so much in the ER.  He’s right, most people don’t
care…but we should.

http://scalpelorsword.blogspot.com/2008/12/1000-sprained-ankle.html

At allergy notes, a discussion of anti-fungal therapy in asthma.
Don’t start inhaling Lotrimin…read the post first, OK?

http://allergynotes.blogspot.com/2008/12/60-of-patients-with-severe-asthma-with.html

A Roger Ballens photograph and search for a genetic diagnosis at the
‘Clinical Cases and Images blog.’

http://casesblog.blogspot.com/2008/12/roger-ballens-photograph-and-search-for.html

Dr. Rich discusses the coming ‘Battle over Universal Healthcare.’  But
not like you might think.  With typical wisdom and foresight, he
offers strategies for flanking the encroaching government limitations
that will likely accompany a national plan.  Take notes, boys and
girls; this is a primer on civil disobedience combined with ‘guerilla
tactics’ that we may all need in a couple of short years.

http://covertrationingblog.com/new-business-models-for-healthcare/strategies-for-the-battle-over-universal-healthcare

Kerri, at ’six until me,’ discusses her experiences with CGM, or
Continuous Glucose Monitoring.  A topic I’m interested in, since my
soon-to-be 12 year old is, like gracious Kerri, a card-carrying,
pump-wearing type I diabetic.

http://sixuntilme.com/blog2/2008/12/dexcom_pros_and_cons.html

My friend Emmy at ‘The pink teeshirt’ is appropriately frustrated by
her oncologist’s rescheduling of her follow-up and by physicians
pushing crazy-expensive drugs on her.  I don’t blame her!  She reminds
us to keep patients first and do the right thing.  Keep reminding us!
We forget…sadly, we forget.

http://thepinkteeshirt.blogspot.com/2009/01/physicians-and-profit.html

A review of health and medicine in 2008, collected by award-winning
medical journalist Amy Tenderich, awaits us at diabetesmine.com.

http://www.diabetesmine.com/2008/12/2008-the-year-in-health-medicine.html

Dr. Val Jones takes on the idea that for profit companies are
inherently less ethical than not for profit ones, and boldly suggests
what I’ve always suspected; that even academic centers can exhibit bad
ethics.  I know, I know…heresy.  But guess what guys and gals, the
truth hurts.  Deal with it.  Thanks to Val for a great post.

http://getbetterhealth.com/are-for-profit-healthcare-companies-inherently-less-ethical-than-non-profit-organizations/2009.01.04

Mudphudder reminds us of something Val was saying.  Academia is not a
synonym for ethical.  Thanks for the warning!  We need to hear it.

http://www.mudphudder.com/2008/12/season-of-giving-comes-to-a-close/

Here’s a quiz:  What do sushi, shampoo and poker have in common?  Go
to this post and find out.

http://www.howtocopewithpain.org/blog/295/jobs-that-cause-pain/

At Code Blog, read about the way even the best nurse can feel
overwhelmed.  I understand.  I feel that way almost every day that I
work.  It’s a testament to all that overwhelmed doctors and nurses
keep coming back for more, in order to do the right thing.

http://www.codeblog.com/archives/tales_from_the_ccu/my-brain-is-overwhelmed-with-info.html

Nancy Brown, PhD is truly poetic when she speaks the truth:  we cannot
analyze the cost-effectiveness of child-rearing.  The joys are too
wonderful for mere fiscal computation to make any sense at all.

http://www.healthline.com/blogs/teen_health/2009/01/h-p-p-y-n-e-w-y-e-r-welcome-to-2009-i.html

Happy Hospitalist offers us a succinct, biting, deliciously sarcastic
but absolutely genuine view of the real barriers to effective care and
efficient medicine.  As we say in the South, ‘It ain’t what you think
it is.’

http://thehappyhospitalist.blogspot.com/2008/12/american-health-care-in-nutshell.html

I’m only two hours from Atlanta and Grady Hospital.  Here’s
fascinating reading about Grady’s financial losses, and ways to stem
the loss of cash, at Insureblog.  Sometimes, it seems, people actually
abuse a hospital’s higher impulses to charity.  Can you imagine it?

http://insureblog.blogspot.com/2009/01/gradys-new-year-resolutions.html

Bongi talks about a triage system we can all understand, but which we
hope never to use.  I thought drunk rednecks were bad to cut each
other!  Turns out, they’re rank amateurs.  Let me here convey my
utmost respect to a doc doing the best for the most, in a situation
where profit is unlikely to raise its head.

http://other-things-amanzi.blogspot.com/2009/01/new-year-triage.html

Speaking of profits, Fitness Fixer Jolie Brookspan may cut into some
orthopedic ones with her post here, about the idea that cruciate
injuries can successfully rehab sans scope.

http://www.healthline.com/blogs/exercise_fitness/2008/12/anterior-cruciate-ligament-acl-surgery.html

David Williams at the Health Business Blog explores a world a little
distant to my emergency department; the difference in compensation of
egg donors and reproductive endocrinologists.  Yikes!  I’m just
excited to get paid a couple of hundred bucks by Medicaid for
resuscitation.

http://www.healthbusinessblog.com/?p=2004

Here’s another great post, offered by Chris at Aequanimitas, reminding
me to quit my whining and remember all the great men and women who
sacrificed to advance modern medicine in some of the most remote,
‘unprofitable’ parts of the world.

http://precordialthump.medbrains.net/2008/12/31/the-cretin-and-the-pharoah/

David Harlow, former Certificate of Need attorney in Massachusetts,
covers quality, cost, regulation and competition in Boston’s ongoing
Partners Healthcare saga.  He asks ’should healthcare resources be
developed in an unregulated manner?’  Read on and enjoy his
intelligent analysis.

http://healthblawg.typepad.com/healthblawg/2008/12/partners-healthcare-competition-regulation-and-the-redeeming-virtues-of-robust-quality-and-cost-data.html

Robin at ‘Survive the Journey’ gives us her take on healthcare reform
and suggests something I’ve advocated before:  tax breaks for those
giving indigent care.  She also asks why we expect charity from an
industry like healthcare, but not from the auto industry.  Very good
question!  Answers, anyone?

http://survivethejourney.blogspot.com/2009/01/in-october-i-wrote-about-our-healthcare.html

And in a fitting finale, Nurse Keith points out the obvious but hard truth: despite all our worries over profits and policies, many people are still really suffering.  We have to remember them, care for them and keep our perspective clear.  Thanks for that gentle reminder, Keith.

http://digitaldoorway.blogspot.com/2008/12/economy-and-its-discontents.html

Next week’s Grand Rounds will be hosted by Barbara Kivowitz at In sickenss and in health.

http://insicknessinhealth.blogspot.com/

So start sending those links!

May God bless you richly and wildly in the coming year!  Thanks so much for your contributions and patience.

If you have a problem with links or if I spelled your name wrong or anything else, e-mail me at edwinleap@gmail.com.

Edwin

I’m not comfortable with that…

I’m about to go to work.  During the course of my emergency department shift, I may see everything from an ankle sprain to a complex poisoning, a dying patient with cardiogenic shock to a corneal abrasion.

In the course of my career, at a mid-sized community emergency department, I have opened the chests of three individuals with stab wounds to the heart.  I have cared for paralysis, profound hypothermia, cardiac rhythm disturbances, SIDS deaths, assorted gun-shot wounds, metabolic derangements, venomous snake-bites, near-drownings and untold other complaints that have afflicted God’s creatures who came through my ER.

The fascinating turn of events in medicine is that, even as my colleagues and I push the limits of our knowledge and skills, medicine is filling up with doctors (and frankly with nurses) whose battle cry is ‘I’m not comfortable with that.’

In my residency (here we go with the old war stories), we flew on a medical helicopter called Lifeline.  On Lifeline shifts, you might fly to and enter a small rural emergency room and be met with utter and unimaginable chaos.  I saw a friend doing a thoracotamy once.  I did escharotamies on the charred skin of terribly burned adults and children.  I lay in the mud intubating a gunshot wound. But do you know the one common denominator?  None of it made me especially comfortable.

I think we’ve lost our way.  Medicine used to be a place where people went when they were willing to take risks to care for the sick and dying.  I mean, we knew everyone died, and most everyone became injured or ill.  So we figured, ‘I’ll give it a shot!’

Now, forgetting the universality of death, forgetting the near universality of error, and ignoring the great value of bold attempts to do good, our culture rejects all risk and our physicians have become soft and cowardly, hiding behind the fear of malpractice or worse…censure by regulatory bodies, loss of profit and inconvenience.

Where are the cowboys and cowgirls?

I won’t be comfortable with everything tonight.  But with God’s help, I’ll sure give it a whirl.

I hope physicians learn to rediscover the joy of risk.

Otherwise, we’ll be stuck with a profession full of insurance adjustors who sound like Bartelby the Scrivener…

‘I would prefer not.’

God help us!  And all our children, and theirs.

Edwin

Help, and sorry about that!

To the very gracious lady who is a poet, and who sent an extremely kind comment, I hit the wrong button and accidentally deleted your comment as spam!  I’m sorry!  Please feel free to send it again, or any other in the future.  Thanks for writing. Sorry I can be such a moron.

Edwin

See my really smart partner’s new book!

My dear friend and partner Doug McGuff is a brilliant man.  He could teach at any medical university and be a much loved instructor.  He thinks of things, on a routine basis, that most of us forgot the day of the exam in medical school.  And he knows the Krebb’s Cycle…by heart.  I thought it was something on the dishwasher!
Doug’s great passion, after his lovely wife and children, is weight training.  He owns a high intensity weight training facility called Ultimate Exercise, in Seneca, SC.

Now, he has a new book on exercise called ‘Body By Science.’  I hope you’ll check it out.  Because the man knows whereof he speaks.

Here’s the link to his book at Amazon.com:  

http://www.amazon.com/Body-Science-Research-Program-Results/dp/0071597174/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1230930939&sr=8-1
The Krebb’s Cycle…is that on the dishwasher?

Edwin

Who are all these people asking me for Lortab?

A few recent patients, on a few recent shifts, have really caused me to question my ability to love humanity.  Like the young drunk driver, with no license, on parole, whose actions resulted in a pelvic fracture and humerus fracture in his riders.  His only concern?  His headache.  (Negative CT scan, by the way.)  Or the relatively young patient whose migraines and assorted other ‘illnesses’ have led him to ride a little scooter everywhere…even though he isn’t even remotely paralyzed.   He always, always, always needs pain medication; despite the boat-loads he takes.  Or the angry, suicidal patient, not remotely psychotic, tearing the fixtures off the walls and threatening all of the staff because we weren’t doing enough, and weren’t doing it quickly enough.

But wait, how about the physicians?  The ones who are happy to leave me in the middle of dispositions because they don’t like the admission rules, or don’t want to do admissions at all, or want me to transfer what’s hard, and send home what isn’t?  Whose mantra is ‘I’m not comfortable with that,’ as if I’m comfortable with everything.  ‘Reattach that limb?  Sure…I work in an ER.’  What about all of the physicians who seem to have decided that medicine is simply annoying, what with all of the patients around.

What about the incessant stream of humanity desperately hoping for disability that they don’t deserve?  (Truly disabled persons should be offended by this rabble.)  As if we haven’t given them enough for free already, their unsubstantiated illnesses, coupled with Herculean determination, will ultimately result in disability check and Medicare coverage for life.  ‘Don’t matter…it’s all government money anyways.’

And what of the untold thousands, and hundreds of thousands, whose lives are a constant pursuit of narcotics and work excuses?  If indeed they turned their formidable resourcefulness to good, if they shunned deception and misrepresentation, if they woke one morning committed to using their talents, why, friends, we would have the cure for every known disease, trans-light-speed engines (built from old ‘57 Chevy engine blocks and leftover Methamphetamine) and an end to hunger in our lifetime!

Medicine is hard.  The public is hard.

Faith and love and hope are hard.

And medicine (especially in an emergency department, but actually everywhere) is one of the most difficult, and fruitful, places to learn to receive and apply the love and truth of God.

What is compassion?  Is it loving the good?  Is it helping the deserving?  Is it kindness to friends?  Is it mercy to the strong?

No, compassion is love despite the evil or undeserving nature of the one receiving it.  Kindness is kindness to friends and family, but also to strangers and enemies.  Mercy is mercy to the weak, to the ones who cannot hurt us if we fail them; who cannot retaliate if we destroy them.

So, I walk a line.  I take care of the people who drive me batty, and work with some people who almost drive me to tirades of profanity.  I don’t deny the evil of the world, and I don’t deny the stupidity or abuse of some of those I meet, I know, I help, I treat.  I don’t subject myself to abuse, nor do I abuse the abusers.  I don’t give everyone all that they want, because what we want is not always best.
But I do it knowing, also, that I am a sinner.  That my faith is predicated on my own unworthiness.  That I am, in a very real sense, a cosmic drug abuser, a spiritual seeker of work excuses, one seeking eternal disability so that I can avoid doing…anything.

I am a worker in the Kingdom who doesn’t want to work.  I am a son of the King who is ‘uncomfortable’ with much that I am asked to do.

I am my patients, and they are me.  I ask for things I don’t need, things that are bad for me and God has the good sense not to prescribe them.  But when I need him, just as those crazies need me, He is there, and I am treated instantly and with absolute love.
Who are all these people asking me for Lortab and work excuses?  They’re me.  And Neither of us have much sense.

But the Creator, the lover of men’s souls, cares for both of us. And that’s a sound reason to go back to the ER tonight; and a sound reason to keep sorting through the madness.

He sorts through mine, after all.

Edwin

Consider what you love, doctor, and love it more

Here’s my column in this month’s Emergency Medicine News.  Please remember to submit to grand rounds; our theme ‘Profit in Health-care!’  Send links or essays to edwinleap@gmail.com.

Happy New Year!

Edwin

Consider what you love

I love the skin of babies, because it is soft, and because it bears none of the scars that time, sickness, injury and heart-ache will leave.  It is a canvas waiting to be filled with kisses, touches and embraces   But I love the skin of the elderly because it is textured with time and stories, like imprints on a vinyl record.  Wrinkles simply represent long life, stored in the many hills and valleys of a body that has seen much, and endured much.  Touching the skin of our patients is such a rare delight.

I love, in an odd way, the sound of patients crying.  Not because I want anyone to suffer.  I love crying because I have cried.  Falling tears and heaving sobs are signs that we are all equally vulnerable.  They mean that we have in common our frustration with this life, and our desire for help, healing or simply comfort.  Sometimes, when a patient is crying, I want to hold them close.  I’m not there yet, but maybe I will be one day.

The sound of breath, smooth and clear or sonorous and rattling, is fascinating to me.  I think I love knowing the difference between good breaths and bad.  It is magnificent to have listened to that sound thousands upon thousands of times.  They say that with every breath, we inhale a molecule of air that Julius Caesar exhaled on the Ides of March.  By now, I can almost hear him say ‘Et tu, Brute?’  It is a gift, an amazing gift, to have heard life move in and out so many times.

Equally fantastic is the sound of the heart.  I am fascinated every time that I hear its amazing twisting movement and contraction, its mysterious expulsion and reception of blood that occurs over and over again until one day, with similar mystery, it ceases.  The heart is special because as I listen, I may put my hand on the wrist or neck of the patient, and feel the pulsations travel down the highway of arteries, feel it beat against my nerve endings and travel back up all the long distance to brain where I sense it.  And across infinity to my mind, where I perceive it.  The heart gets inside my head, you might say, and its beating can thrill as much as its cessation terrifies.

I am enamored of examining the abdomen, wherein lie so many organs, so many blood vessels, babies in the process of becoming, tumors in the process of destroying.  To examine the abdomen is to shake a Christmas package, wondering what might be inside.  I love the feel of appendicitis, though I am sorry for those who endure it.  There is such joy in seeing the wisdom of our teachers made manifest in our hands, and confirmed in the truth of our suspicions when the diagnosis is made.

The smooth symmetry of intact limbs is artistic, but equally wonderful is the way I can know, frequently without any test, that a limb is broken.  The many shades of blue and gray that surround fractures are testament to the underlying dysfunction.  There is an awful artistry to the jagged, disordered, fractal geometry of broken bones.

Wounds of all sorts are oddly amazing, and I have touched so many that I almost enjoy the reproducible warmth of blood, and its smell, as it pours across my gloved hand and I admire its lovely scarlet shades, my delight nearly vampiric.  Holes and slashes from weapons are unfortunate portals into the mysteries of the living, and sometimes the dead, human body.  I hate to see such suffering; but I am a voyeur of the flesh, having spent so many years hovering over it and touching it.

And death, death!  The lessons it has taught me over the years! It is sudden and slow, painful and painless.  It is tragedy and loss, hope and opportunity.  And it is a thing unlike any other.  I have seen life depart in young and old alike.  I know, through death, that there is something indescribably holy that enlivens us all before that moment and that leaves with breath and heartbeat.  I sense, in that fact, indescribable hope.

We humans are such pieces of wonder.  Every year that I have the privilege of practicing medicine, I realize that what I’m actually practicing is far more.  Medicine is the word for the study of the soul and flesh that dwell together in humans, and by which we physicians seek (in our limited ways) to put it right while it walks the earth; and before it is lain to rest in the earth.

Spend a day, now and then, in amazement.  Love the broken, touch the sick, caress the dying, shake hands with the scandalous and wicked, embrace the mad.  Learn the feel of their heartbeats and the sound of their breaths, the color of their eyes and the textures of their hair.  Each of them is a wonder no less than the stars.

Learn to see your career that way, and you’ll be able to keep going from body to body, wonder to wonder, without misery.  Let this be the year you fall back in love with your career by falling back in love with humanity, with the amazing structure and function of each human, and with the eternal worth of each and every life entrusted to your hands.

Grand Rounds for January 6, 2009

Greetings all!  I’m hosting Grand Rounds for January 6.  I want to tell you about the theme.

Profit in health-care.

What do I mean?  Well, lots of things are driving my thinking here.  The Obama administration may create long-lasting changes in the reimbursement of health-care, up to and including a single-payer system.  To increase the numbers of primary care physicians, there’s talk of paying for the medical education of those students interested in primary care, so that they won’t have a burden of debt and feel compelled to enter high-paying specialties.  (The tacit assumption reasonably being that their primary-jobs won’t be very lucrative.)  All over the house of medicine, we find invective against the pharmaceutical industry; for manipulating data and (let’s be honest) because they seek to make hefty profits.

And if we, as physicians, want to make plenty of cash, are we hypocritical when we come down on big Pharma?  I mean, is everything we do, and recommend, really evidence-based and in the best interest of our patients?  I don’t know all the answers…I’m just posing the question.
So, as physicians and others in the greater health-care world, what do we really think about profit?  We’re taking care of people in need, many of whom have limited incomes and no insurance.  Humans don’t always choose their illnesses (though they often do).  Many really need medical care; some just desire it.

As health-care providers, we’re often working in dangerous environments, subjecting ourselves to the risks of infection, physical harm, lawsuits, exhaustion, relationship troubles and burn-out.

In light of all that, should we be turning a profit?  Should we feel entitled to lots of money?  Are we any different from other necessary professions?  Should your contractor build houses at minimal profit, since people need shelter? Should auto-makers sell cars without much profit, since people need transportation?  It’s an interesting question.

Will young people endure medical education and practice without the promise of significant profit?  Will the young physicians now in practice continue?  Or, if we decided to pay less, would they simply become clock-in, clock-out factor workers?

Does the promise of financial gain make us better providers or worse?

Does profit compromise our morality, our compassion for those in need, or even our faith (to those so disposed)?

OK, hit me!  Send links and responses to my e-mail at:

edwinleap@gmail.com

As before, you don’t have to follow this theme.  But if you do, I’ll be interested to see what you have to say.  I’ll tell you my thoughts on January 6.

If you don’t blog, and want to add your thoughts, send me an e-mail.  I’ll make a place to post your opinion.  If you don’t want your name attached, just say the word.

Have a great day, and a blessed, Happy New Year!

Edwin

Do less; your kids will love it…

This was my column in the Greenville News on Christmas Eve.  I hope you find it relevant to your life, or the life of someone you care about!  Because my formatting isn’t working lately, here’s the link to the actual online column, as well.

http://www.greenvilleonline.com/article/20081224/OPINION/812240348/1016/OPINION

Against the serene backdrop of our theoretically peaceful Christmas season, I believe we are a nation of men and women, boys and girls completely overwhelmed by our schedules.  Do you doubt it?  Let’s look at the facts.

We work, belong to clubs, go to church, go to the gym, volunteer to ‘give back,’ and last of all, try to squeeze in time with our spouses and children.  Our children’s activities dwarf our own in scope and schedule.  One child may, in any given week, have school (with homework), soccer, swimming, dance, horse-back riding, parties, music lessons and tutoring.

For an eye-opening bit of truth, we should all ask ourselves one thunderous, salient question about our pace and our ‘busy-ness.’  The question is ‘why?’  Why do we do it?  Of course, we have to work.  And we enjoy social interaction to a degree.  But why do we do all the rest?  Is it because we believe we have to?  And if so, who said?

I suspect it was that universally powerful group known as ‘they.’  You may have heard of them.  ‘They’ are apparently a quasi-governmental organization based on human anxiety, loneliness and restlessness, funded by assorted membership fees and committed to the advancement of human misery and exhaustion.

‘They say everyone should volunteer.  They say you should work out three times a week.  They say that children need lots of activities and “socialization.”  They say that kids who do certain activities are more likely to get into good colleges and get good jobs.  They say that if you don’t get the right job you’ll be unhappy.  They say you won’t succeed in life without the right degree from the right school.  They say your children really don’t want time with their parents.  They say every kid needs a cell-phone, television and computer in order to be normal.’  I have to tell you, I can’t stand ‘them.’

The truth is that when we listen to ‘them,’ we push ourselves too hard for very little gain.  I know people who are literally slaves to activities; especially the activities of their kids.  They don’t rest and they don’t enjoy life.  They are worn, haggard and out of money.

Furthermore, it is my absolute conviction that most of the time, children actually enjoy staying home and simply playing…no team, no competition, no trophy, no uniform.  Children, far more than adults, understand what it means just to be.

Families that are indentured to activity don’t enjoy one another.  Parents and children seldom sit quietly at bedtime and just listen to one another breathe.  They’re frantic to finish homework, check e-mail, send text-messages and engage in all of the other propellants that serve to keep humans distracted from the terror of monsters like quiet, simplicity, peace and interpersonal communications.

I wish that we could stop listening to ‘them’ and so learn, in part, to defeat our own motion.  If we did, we might eventually overcome our endless desire to please, our need for constant distraction and learn to love just being together.

I mean, what are the dangers of staying home and slowing down?  Fewer friendships?  Many of them were superficial anyway.  Less resume material?  Sanity and calm might make for better interviews and more thorough work.  It would be a wash, at least.  The greatest danger might be the reality of facing our families, day after day, evening after evening, without a reason to walk away, drive away or click away.  (Ghastly, isn’t it?)

But what about the benefits?  Well, if you want practical ones, we might drive less and spend less.  Good for the environment, good for the pocketbook.  When we stay home, when we resist the inner and external urge for constant motion and stimulation, we will find our joys simpler but more wonderful.  We can actually talk, in person! We may play games, work on projects, share meals we cook together or enjoy a movie without the press of the crowd and cost of the ticket.  The proximity and commitment of time together will teach us deep things about those we love.  And perhaps teach us to love ourselves without anyone else’s approval.

This Christmas, this New Year, give yourself the gift of less and the gift of no.  Engage in fewer activities and say no to people who won’t let you slow down.  In the process, I promise that you and your children will end up with ‘more.’  And will more often want to say ‘yes’ to spending time together.

Merry Christmas and thanks!

To all of my readers,

Thank you!  Thank you for your friendship.  Thank you for reading my thoughts and ideas.  I appreciate all of the time you take to visit my site, and especially the time you take to comment.

I don’t always answer, and I’m sorry about that.  I’m a ‘poor correspondent,’ but I love hearing from you.  The thing is, between writing the blog, writing the columns I write each month, going to the ER to work and spending time with family, I don’t always have the time to do it.  Please don’t take it as indifference or bad manners; it’s mainly just the confines of a ridiculously short 24 hour day.

Thank you for opening your hearts to me!  For telling me when I touch you!  For letting me see inside, and for encouraging me!  When you let me know that something I wrote helped you in a hard time, or in a struggle, or in your practice or walk of faith, you move me to keep coming back to the keyboard.  And you help me to remember that writing is part of my calling in this life; a thing I must not, cannot ignore.

I am thankful to God for your lives and that you are part of mine.

I hope that God gives you a delightful and merry Christmas!  I hope Santa is good to you.  I pray that love and truth surround you.

And that you have as much fun as I have already had with my wife and kids.

May Emmanuel come to you wherever you are, and ransom you as he has ransomed me.

Edwin

I want to be Santa!

I want to be Santa Claus. It seems an appealing career. I’m not terribly overweight, but I do love cookies. I could fill out that red suit in no time fat…I mean no time flat. I like snow, and have always wanted to visit the North Pole. I enjoy Christmas music and with the right icy castle, the right reindeer, the right staff of busy elves and my wife by my side as Mrs. Claus, I think I could give it a go. I don’t think she would be very excited about being plump and white haired, so we could probably make an exception. (Besides, I’ve seen some ‘Mrs. Claus’ costumes in catalogs that I’d much prefer to see her wear). The children, all avid toy lovers, would most certainly want to be in the business. Forget medicine! Fetch me my sleigh! The main reason I’d like to be Santa is that I like to give gifts. My wife says that for this reason alone, I would make a good Kris Kringle. I love is knowing what a few people desire, knowing what moves them or makes them smile, then providing that thing. If I had Santa’s budget, Santa’s magic, Santa’s apparent time travel capabilities and Santa’s obvious omniscience, I could really have a good time. I’m always sad when I know that people receive gifts from the ones who should known them best, but the gifts have no meaning. Gifts are sometimes limited by finances, of course, but that’s not what I mean. I’m talking about times when gifts that should be meaningful are meaningless because the giver didn’t take the time to know the heart of the recipient. I hate knowing that children are ignored by parents who are too busy, or too drunk, too self-occupied or too stoned to care. I hate knowing that mothers get sweeper attachments and fathers receive socks, when what they wanted were violin lessons and a Golden Retriever puppy for duck hunting. But when it comes to giving gifts, it seems that the best things are seldom things at all. If I were Santa, I would want the power to give those gifts that resonate in the halls of the heart. Because people are desperate for their hearts’ desires to be known and filled. We are seldom honest with our loved ones about what we truly want. Of course, we are seldom honest with ourselves. Perhaps we don’t tell the truth because have spent our lives so occupied with busy-ness and entertainment that we’ve never bothered to look inside our own wonderful, broken hearts. Having spent some time around people, a lot of people, I think I know what I would be dispensing if I were Santa. I would muster all of my magic and give things elemental. I would give freedom to people enslaved by drugs, by food and by the cruel words of others that hold them down. I would give them liberation from the terror of self, by showing them that all of the bad things they think inside their own minds about themselves are false. I would let them wake up, check their stockings by the fire, and suddenly see themselves beautiful and capable, strong and good. I would lift depression like a cloud blown on a winter wind. I would give children the attention and genuine affection of their parents. I would give relief and hope to those suffering with the pain of diseases, so that on Christmas morning they felt not an ounce of discomfort. I would give back the missing children, and restore the relationships of estranged families. I would renew the passion of marriages that have been mere rote, elevate them from misery to delight and let Christmas morning be like a reunion of lost lovers. If I were Santa, I would visit the dying with visions of heaven so wonderful that their fear was banished like darkness before the rising dawn of Christmas morning. I would let men and women wake to see their dreams as possibilities, and give them some thing, some opportunity, some chance meeting that would send them laughing into the rest of their lives, doing what God made them to do with absolute abandon. If I were Santa, I would even comfort the arthritic bones of old dogs, so they could chase one another once more. If I were Santa, I would do so much. But I’m not. I guess the best gifts are still up to all of us for now. Trust me, when I get the job, you’ll know.